Nitto Terra Grappler G2 vs. Toyo Open Country AT2 vs. BFG KO2: Which is better?

All-terrain tires are essential for those who use their cars year-round in different road conditions. The Nitto Terra Grappler G2, Toyo Open Country AT2, and the BFG KO2 are three of the best on the market. 

Whether you are looking for comfortability, longevity, or a great deal, one of these all-terrain tires is perfect for your car. This guide provides you a detailed breakdown and comparison of the essential specifications for each of these tremendous all-terrain tires. 

Nitto terra grappler G2 vs. Toyo Open Country AT2 vs. BFG KO2: Comparison Table

All three of these tires have excellent capabilities and attributes that make them attractive for all-terrain driving. However, each of them has different benefits. The all-terrain tires you buy depend on the specs that you are looking for. 

Overall, the best way of getting a snapshot comparison is with a table like the one below:

Nitto Terra Grappler G2 Toyo Open Country AT2 and BFG KO2
A comparison between Nitto Terra Grappler G2, Toyo Open Country AT2, and BFG KO2

Specifications:

 Nitto Terra Grappler G2 Toyo Open Country AT2 BFG KO2
Available Rim Sizes16’’, 17’’, 18’’, 20’’, 22’’, 24’’15’’, 16’’, 17’’, 18’’, 20’’, 22’’15’’, 16’’, 17’’, 18’’, 20’’, 22’’
Weight37 - 74 lbs26 -79 lbs 32.1 - 72.6 lbs
WeightNoNoThree-Peak Mountain Snowflake Rating
Treadwear Warranty+ 50,000 miles for LT-metric and flotation sizes
+ 65,000 miles for hard metric sizes
+ 50,000 miles for LT-metric and flotation sizes
+ 65,000 miles for hard metric sizes
50,000 miles

Before diving into the detailed comparison below, let’s take a look at what other users comment on Nitto Terra Grappler G2, Toyo Open Country AT2, and BFG KO2:


  • I agree, we have Toyo’s on all our vehicles, long wearing tire, nice ride on E rated, slight noise on roads AT2 series. Also have Toyo’s on my wife’s car, nice ride, long wear warranty and believe it or not, Blizzard rated for South Louisiana use, they’re just fine! (AbitaPro – https://www.ford-trucks.com/forums/1496371-toyo-open-country-at2-or-nitto-terra-grappler.html)
  • I ran the toyo at2’s on my previous jk. Best tires I ever had hands down. Uber Quiet, very responsive on mountain curves, great customer service, priced affordable, great treadlife warranty, and I prefer the looks as opposed to other all terrains. (dawhitesJKU – https://www.wranglerforum.com/threads/toyo-at-ii-vs-nitto-terra-grapplers.1467473/)
  • I am currently running a P285/70R17 Toyo AT2 and I love them. They literally look identical to the nittos but have a more aggressive looking sidewall which is why I went with them. My mom is running a bigger size nitto on her jeep but I still feel like mine have that more aggressive look thanks to the sidewall.” (Yfunyuns93 – https://www.wranglerforum.com/threads/toyo-at-ii-vs-nitto-terra-grapplers.1467473/)
  • Toyo is a great tire. I had the ATII for 4 years. They worked excellent in sand snow ice and fire roads. They are not severe weather rated. And the carcass of the tire is not as stout as true BFG. All around excellent tires. The BFG ATKo2’s are also excellent tires. I have used them in mud snow and ice. They track really well off-road and on. Yes they are a heavy tire and you will feel it on the road. These tires are severe weather rated and they work very well in bad conditions. I do highly recommend them both. If you live in a climate that gets snow and use them off-road a lot go with the BFG. If you don’t need the severe weather rating and do a lot of commuting and smaller amounts of off-roading go with the ATII. You really can’t go wrong with either. (STPICKENS – https://www.overlandbound.com/forums/threads/bfg-a-t-k02-or-toyo-open-country-a-t-ii.8503/)

Nitto Terra Grappler G2 vs. Toyo Open Country AT2 vs. BFG KO2: Detailed Analysis

All-terrain tires are critical for drivers who push their vehicles’ capabilities. These tires need excellent handling and braking, rugged durability, and versatile performance both off-road and on city streets. The Nitto Terra Grappler G2, Toyo Open Country AT2, and BFG KO2 provide these attributes with some minor differences explained below.  

Off-Road Performance

The Winner: BFG KO2

All-terrain tires are an excellent option for those who enjoy off-roading. The best performance factors for off-road tires are handling smoothness, vibrations, and durability against the terrain. 

Nitto Terra Grappler G2 is designed to provide excellent traction and grip on all types of terrain. The tire is also very durable and can withstand rough use. However, the off-roading capability of Nitto Terra Grappler G2 is not as good as the other tires on this list.

nitto terra G2 off-road performance
The off-roading capability of Nitto Terra Grappler G2 is not as good as the other tires on this list – Credit: Tikray

The Toyo Open Country AT2 all-terrain tire has good off-road handling and maneuverability. They also last longer and handle better in off-road conditions than the Terra Grappler. The best part about Toyo’s open country tires is that they have deep sipes, not knobby tread, meaning that they produce excellent and smooth handling for off-road conditions without much vibration or noise. 

toyo open country at2
The Toyo Open Country AT2 all-terrain tire has good off-road handling and maneuverability – Credit: BrotherRob

But the tire with the best off-road performance is the BFG KO2. The BFG KO2 is the best all-terrain tire for off-roading because of the gnarly three-dimensional tread design. The knobby rubber on the tire edge makes them the most rugged and best handling tire for off-road conditions. That’s why the BFG KO2 is the best option if you are looking for a durable and extremely heavy-duty off-road tire. 

bfg ko2 off-road performance
BFG KO2 is the best option if you are looking for a durable and extremely heavy-duty off-road tire – Credit: Shiftonthefly1

On-Road Performance

The winner: Toyo Open Country AT2

You buy all-terrain tires because they work for all road conditions. So, it is vital that they provide a solid ride over rugged off-road terrain and then transition smoothly to the city’s streets. 

To start, the big knobby rubber of the BFG KO2 tires makes these tires bite into the road too much and are difficult to drive on asphalt with some vibrations. This is also the case, to a lesser degree, for the Nitto Terra Grappler tires, which also have a deep tread and some knobby edges. 

bfg ko2 on-road performance
BFG KO2 On-road – Credit: trusty

However, the Toyo Open Country AT2 tires are by far the best for on-road performance. They have a sleek and low-profile tread design with deep sipes for excellent traction. Besides, low-profile treads allow for smooth maneuverability on asphalt.

toyo open country at2 on-road
The Toyo Open Country AT2 tires are by far the best for on-road performance on this list – Credit: Ramitt

Snow and Ice Performance

The Winner: BFG KO2

Inevitably, if you use your all-terrain tires all year round, you will drive through some ice and snow.

First of all, the limited outer tread on the Nitto Terra Grappler G2 makes turning in off-road ice and snow very difficult. That explains why these tires are not as good at this category as the two on this list.

Nitto Terra Grappler G2 On Snow
Nitto Terra Grappler G2 On Snow – Credit: BatWolf

The deep-set sipes on the Toyo Open Country AT2s give predictable handling even in icy conditions. The traction is spread out evenly over the tire’s surface, giving them better traction over rough and snowy terrain with little in the way of vibrations.

The BFG KO2 tires are the best on this list for snow and ice performance. The deep track bites well into icy roads, even while turning or facing off-road conditions. 

bfg ko2 on snow
The deep and thick tread on these all-terrain BFG KO2 tires is the best on this list for snow and ice performance – Credit: f150forum.com

Noise Level

The Winner: Toyo Open Country AT2

Only one of the tires on this list is best suitable for you for those looking for a smooth and quiet ride.

The BFG KO2 and the Nitto Terra Grappler G2 are not too bad for sound and vibrations. However, the deep and semi-rigid walls of the Nitto Terra Grappler G2s and the knobby rubber edges of the BFG KO2 make them both quite noisy rides. 

Contrarily, the best part about the Toyo Open Country AT2 tires is that they are the quietest all-terrain tires on this list. Although the sipes in these tires are very deep, they are reasonably smooth on the tire’s exterior edge providing traction without producing vibrations and noise. 

toyo at2 noise level
If you are looking for a quiet ride, look no further than the Toyo Open Country AT2 all-terrain tires – Credit: pawpaw

Treadwear Warranty

The winner: Nitto Terra Grappler and Toyo Open Country AT2

A warranty on tires that you use for all conditions, mainly off-road, is the peace of mind that every driver wants. The treadwear warranty covers wear and tear on your tires from everyday driving up to the manufacturer’s specific mileage. 

The Nitto Terra Grappler and Toyo Open Country tires offer warranties that last up to 65,000 miles, making them the best choice for a warranty on this list. On the other hand, the BFG KO2 tires are only slightly less covered with a warranty covering 50,000 miles


Price

The winner: Nitto Terra Grappler G2

If price concerns you, the following details rank these three all-terrain tires from the cheapest to the most expensive.

Though you may get what you pay for, the Nitto Grapplers are the most affordable set of all-terrain times on this list, starting at around $161. BFG KO2s are more expensive at around $190, and Toyo Open Country AT2 tires are the most expensive at $260.


Final Thoughts

 Nitto Terra Grappler G2
Terra Grappler G2

Best Budget

Toyo Open Country AT2
Open Country AT2

Best For On-road Performance

 BFG KO2
BFG KO2

Best For Off-road Performance

All-terrain tires are for everyday use all year long. However, if you are looking for something in particular, this article should help you decide.

  • The BFG KO2s are the best all-terrain tire for you if you want rugged dependability, off-road domination, and great snow performance.
  • If you are looking for smooth rides alongside reliability, the Toyo Open Country AT2 is your best option.
  • In case you are on budget and searching an affordable all-terrain tire, Nitto Terra Grappler G2 will be an suitable choice.

Read more: KM3 vs. KO2 vs. STT Pro: Which Is Better?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.